HomeNewsBusinessGeorgia Power, State Energy Regulators Reach Tentative Deal on Plant Vogtle Costs

Georgia Power, State Energy Regulators Reach Tentative Deal on Plant Vogtle Costs

Author

Date

by Dave Williams | Oct 14, 2021 | Capitol Beat News Service

ATLANTA – Georgia Power would be allowed to pass on to customers $2.1 billion of the costs of completing the first of two new nuclear reactors at Plant Vogtle under a stipulation agreement outlined Thursday.

But the Atlanta-based utility wouldn’t be permitted to start recovering those costs until one month after the reactor unit goes into commercial operation, next June under the current completion schedule.

“Neither party to the stipulation received everything it wanted, but instead what staff believes is a fair and just compromise,” Steven Roetger, an analyst with the Georgia Public Service Commission’s (PSC) Public Interest Advocacy (PIA) Staff, told commissioners during a hearing on the agreement.

The PSC voted in August to stop approving incremental cost increases incurred at the long-delayed, over-budget nuclear expansion at the plant south of Augusta. Instead, commissioners have opted to postpone deciding how much of the cost overruns Georgia Power customers will have to bear until after Unit 3, the first of the two new reactors, is completed.

The project, originally projected to cost $14 billion, has ballooned to at least $26 billion.

At the same time, the completion dates have been postponed from 2016 for the first unit and 2017 for the second until 2022 and 2023, due in part to the bankruptcy of prime contractor Westinghouse and, more recently, to workforce shortages arising from the coronavirus pandemic.

Representatives of Georgia Power and the PIA Staff signed off on the stipulation agreement on Wednesday.

Under a key provision in the agreement, Georgia Power will not be allowed to pass on to customers any of the nearly $1.5 billion guarantee Japan-based Toshiba – the parent company of Westinghouse – committed to the project until after the commission decides how much of that guarantee has been spent prudently.

The agreement also for the first time gives the PSC the right to review all operating and maintenance expenses associated with Unit 3 following its completion if the reactor is not performing up to expectations.

In that case, Georgia Power would have to prove that any electrical production that falls below the expected 1,102 megawatts of generating capacity was not the result of “unreasonable or imprudent” construction.

“One of the major concerns we had was performance reliability,” Roetger testified Thursday. “We felt it was necessary to provide this commission an opportunity to review … all of the costs.”

During cross-examination of Roetger and two Georgia Power executives, lawyers for big industrial customers and environmental and consumer advocacy groups complained the agreement would let Georgia Power raise customer rates following the completion of Unit 3 next summer at the same time the utility already is scheduled to file its next regular rate case with the PSC.

“Predictability in budgeting … can be essential for businesses trying to navigate a challenging economy,” said Clay Jones, a lawyer representing the Georgia Association of Manufacturers.

Residential customers under the stipulation agreement would see a net increase of $3.78 a month starting next July, based on the typical usage of 1,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity.

Liz Coyle, executive director of the consumer advocacy group Georgia Watch, said that’s too much to pay beginning just one month after Unit 3 goes into commercial operation when there’s no guarantee the new reactor will perform properly. She cited an example where an AP1000 reactor in China – the same technology Plant Vogtle is using – did not perform reliably for a year.

“Many Georgians, especially those living on fixed incomes, are already having difficulty paying their power bills,” Coyle said. “Even $4 more a month can be problematic in terms of making ends meet.”

Roetger said the agreement strikes a necessary balance between the interests of customers and Georgia Power.

“I understand there are people who are struggling,” he said. “But we have to look at the entire state … and make sure we have a utility that can provide safe and reliable power and is financially sound.”

The commission is scheduled to vote on the agreement Nov. 2.

This story is available through a news partnership with Capitol Beat News Service, a project of the Georgia Press Educational Foundation.

2 COMMENTS

  1. I’m sure that the $3.78 increase on our monthly bill will be permanent, and eventually raised.
    When these reactors are completed, will we still have to pay the Environmental Compliance Cost and the Nuclear Construction Cost Recovery? I bet so. These two things alone are over $20 per month on my power bill.

  2. and your taxes will go up to pay the utility bills of those who live in government housing and poor old people who worked all their lives will have to turn their power of and run the risk of freezing to death or dying of heat stroke. greed from the utility companies plain and simple. why do we have to pay for this to be built? will it not pay for itself from the sale of the power it generates?

Recent posts

Recent comments

Sheila Stahl on Letter to the Editor
Tedd Antonacci on Savoring a victory over trash
Christine Slendak on Opinion: A Letter of Thanksgiving
Randall Sutton on Savoring a victory over trash
Frank Bush on Faith: Thankfulness
Doug Herman on Faith: Thankfulness
Stoney Turnage on Vax Up Augusta Documents
Dee Stafford on Area Briefs for Nov. 16
Phillip Williams on Area Briefs for Nov. 16
Jerry Murphy on At Work With: Jerry Murphy
Jerry Murphy on At Work With: Jerry Murphy
Robert Green on Area Briefs for Nov. 16
Juliann McCraney on FAITH: Ruminating on Creation
Wilford Verneau on FAITH: Ruminating on Creation
Marcie Wilhelmi on Veterans Day Salute: Jeff Foley
Andrew Edmunds on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Mahi Majanovic on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Robert Green on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Larry Garner on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
THOMAS SUMNER on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Bill Lesshafft on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Phillip Williams on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Richard Ashworth on Letter To Editor: Bob Young
Tony Walden on Letter to the Editor
THOMAS SUMNER on Letter to the Editor
Allen Wylds on Letter to the Editor
Janie Terrell Peel on Doctor Serving Up Java In Retirement
Kelly Wagner on Bath Gardens Being Restored
Dennis Perry on Faith: Now We Know
Carolyn Vickers on Veterans Day Parade in Question
Christine Slendak on Veterans Day Parade in Question
Gwen Fulcher Young on Short Getaways: Newberry, S.C.
Thomas Plowden on Short Getaways: Newberry, S.C.
James Blanchard on Faith: Habit or Commitment?
Jim Sechrist on Faith: Habit or Commitment?
Jimmy Clark on Matthews Motors Expands
Amanda Main on An Examined Digital Life
Christine Slendak on Opinion: Meet the Blythers
Nancy blanchard on Opinion: Meet the Blythers
Doug Herman on Faith: Hope
William Harper on Dine And Dish: Hildebrandt’s
Gwen Fulcher Young on Dine And Dish: Hildebrandt’s
Thomas Yarbrough on Duncan Will Seek Another Term
Mark Sisson on Letter to the Editor
Robert Green on Letter to the Editor
Phillip Williams on Letter to the Editor
Ayman Fadel on Letter to the Editor
Jim Sechrist on Letter to the Editor
Bill Lesshafft on Letter to the Editor
Penny Danner on Letter to the Editor
Russell Smith on Letter to the Editor
Thomas Plowden on Letter to the Editor
Juliann McCraney on Letter to the Editor
Jim Bible on Letter to the Editor
Bill Harrell on Opinion: The Little Switch
Penny Danner on Opinion: The Little Switch
Bill Harrell on Opinion: The Little Switch
Tedd Antonacci on Opinion: The Little Switch
Doug Herman on Dine and Dish: Toki Jr.
Michael Meyers on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Stoney Turnage on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Amanda Morris on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Catherine McKnight on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Catherine McKnight on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Christine Slendak on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Thomas Hodges on Opinion: As Augusta Turns
Bill Lesshafft on Opinion: Do You Go to Church?
Sylvia Cooper on Keeping Up With: Venus Cain
Virgil Huston on Letter to the Editor
Robert Green on Letter to the Editor
Charles Sanford on Letter to the Editor
Ayman Fadel on Letter to the Editor
Tom Tinley on Letter to the Editor
charlie hannah on Keeping Up With: Venus Cain
Craig Spinks on Keeping Up With: Venus Cain
Craig Spinks on Keeping Up With: Venus Cain
Phillip Williams on Local High School Football Scores
Leonard Zimmerman Jr on Keen Signs Stays Prepared for Change
Pam Dunaway on Faith: The Death of Death
Betty Parker on Faith: God Bless America?
Michael Meyers on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Tedd Antonacci on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Michael Meyers on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Catherine McKnight on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Phillip Williams on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Bill Lesshafft on Opinion: So Much to Talk About
Andrew Edmunds on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
charlie coleman on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Thomas Yarbrough on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Michael Meyers on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Juliann McCraney on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Tedd Antonacci on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Richard Harrison on Opinion: It’s a Clean Audit
Jimmy Rivers on At Work With: George Berry
Ronnie Mullis on Millage Rates Explained
Gene Walker on Millage Rates Explained
Wilford Verneau on Faith: Cotton Candy
Simona Chilton on Opinion: Who Foots the Bill?